A rising star in the world of cinema, Minha Kim, has taken a leap into the spotlight with her lead performance in “A Girl with Closed Eyes,” directed by Chun Sun-young. Following her impactful role in the critically acclaimed AppleTV+ series “Pachinko,” Kim plays a young woman ensnared in a web of murder accusations surrounding a celebrated author. The film premiered at the prestigious Busan International Film Festival, generating buzz for its intriguing premise but ultimately revealing a script plagued by inconsistencies.
Set against the picturesque backdrop of Hongcheon, a region characterized by its provincial charm, “A Girl with Closed Eyes” begins with chilling immediacy. Min-ju, played by Kim, is found at the scene of a murder, gripping a smoking gun and standing over the lifeless body of renowned writer Jeong Sang-woo, portrayed by Lee Ki-woo. The film sets the stage for a gripping crime thriller that seems to promise clever storytelling intertwined with profound character exploration. Her subsequent arrest leads to a deeper unraveling of her identity as Lee In-seon, a character steeped in the mystery of an unsolved kidnapping from two decades prior.
The narrative begins weaving layers of intrigue as Min-ju claims that Jeong, her tormentor who is now dead, used her traumatic past for his literary gain. The plot thickens when her former classmate, detective Park Min-ju (Choi Hee-seo), is summoned to sift through the layers of truth and deception. The personal strife between the two women, magnified by unresolved issues from their shared past, infuses the film with emotional depth.
Artful Homage or Derivative Design?
One of the film’s most noteworthy aspects is how it pays homage to cinematic influences while navigating its own narrative path. References to celebrated works including Bong Joon-ho’s “Memories of Murder” and Stephen King’s “Misery” form the backbone of its storytelling framework. Yet, while these influences illuminate moments within the film, they often appear to overshadow originality. The repetitive nods to other films divert attention rather than serving as insightful tributes.
The intricate plot structure appears initially sturdy but quickly unravels as the film descends into convoluted twists and red herrings. This chaotic shift in the second half of the film ironically undermines its earlier successes, showcasing how an engaging premise can falter beneath its self-imposed complexity. Moments designed for tension start to feel contrived, leading to an unsatisfying resolution that leaves audiences grappling with a series of unfulfilled expectations.
Performance: The Heartbeat of the Film
Despite the narrative shortcomings, the performances, especially those by Minha Kim and Choi Hee-seo, invigorate the film. Kim’s portrayal showcases an emotional spectrum, effortlessly oscillating between the roles of a villain seeking revenge and a victim seeking justice. Her evolution throughout the story highlights an ability to embody complex characters while revealing underlying motivations that resonate.
Choi’s portrayal of Park, the detective, adds another layer as her character struggles with personal and professional dilemmas. The dynamic between the two leads offers a rich exploration of friendship that has been tarnished but remains fraught with unspoken connections. Their interactions are electric, capturing the viewer’s attention even when the plot falters.
Visually, Chun Sun-young’s directorial approach is commendable, with skilled cinematography that brings Hongcheon to life, enhancing the emotional tone of the story. The film is laden with dynamically staged sequences that draw the viewer into the escalating tension. It is evident that Chun possesses an artistic sensibility that could flourish under a more coherent script.
While “A Girl with Closed Eyes” is a spectacle for the eyes and the performances stand tall, the film ultimately stumbles under the weight of its complex narrative ambitions. It serves as a reminder that even the most captivating visuals and compelling performances can fall short when the underlying story fails to uphold its promise. As an ambitious debut, the film offers potential but leaves us hoping for a more refined script in future endeavors.
Leave a Reply