The film industry has undergone significant changes in recent years, with the arrival of Covid lockdowns and the streaming revolution. One noticeable trend that has emerged is the extreme top-loading at the box office. In 2023, three films, namely Barbie, The Super Mario Bros. Movie, and Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse, accounted for a staggering 17.8 percent of the domestic theatrical total, amounting to approximately $1.6 billion in ticket sales. This top-heavy distribution of revenue raises the question: would the film industry benefit from a pruning of its top earners?
Comparing the box office shares of recent years to earlier, healthier years unveils a concerning disparity. Between 2015 and 2019, a period that witnessed the success of blockbuster hits like Black Panther and Jurassic World, the top three films, on average, accounted for only about 14.5 percent of the box office revenue. Even in the preceding years from 2010 to 2014, despite the presence of films like Avatar and The Avengers, the top three films averaged just 10.9 percent of the total box office. However, in 2023, the top three films held a combined share that was 63 percent higher than that of a dozen years prior.
The concentration of audience interest in a small number of films at the very top can be attributed to several factors. The evaporation of lower- and middle-range films, the disappearance of older viewers, and the extreme concentration of interest through social media all play a role in driving audiences towards the top earners. This phenomenon has led to a decline in the popularity of films in the lower ranks.
Analyzing the available data reveals a striking disparity in earnings among films. After deducting the revenue generated by the top three films, approximately 580 other films shared the remaining $7.4 billion in 2023, with an average earnings of $12.7 million each. This represents a decrease from earlier years, such as 2010 when a larger group of around 650 films earned an average of about $14.5 million each, which is approximately 14 percent higher than the 2023 average. Consequently, the box office has become distorted, with an excessive concentration of revenue at the top and a lack of substantial earnings at the bottom.
While the advent of streaming platforms has provided an alternative revenue stream, the top-heavy distribution of box office earnings continues to pose challenges for the industry as a whole. The overemphasis on a small number of films limits opportunities for other filmmakers and industry professionals to thrive. This concentration reduces diversity in content and creative voices, hindering the growth and sustainability of the film industry.
Considering the current state of the film industry, a pruning of the top earners may be necessary to restore balance and health. By allowing other films to have a greater share of the box office, the industry can nurture a broader range of talent and ensure a more diverse cinematic landscape. This, in turn, would create opportunities for a variety of stories and genres to flourish, providing audiences with a richer and more engaging film-going experience.
The extreme top-loading of the box office in recent years has created a distorted distribution of revenue within the film industry. This concentration of earnings at the top limits opportunities for other films and industry professionals, hindering the overall health and sustainability of the industry. By pruning the top earners and diversifying the box office landscape, the film industry can foster greater creativity, diversity, and long-term success.
Leave a Reply